Are my stats bugged?

[Leba]

Hi I need someone to take a look at this and tell me if I got something wrong, because I'm under the impression that something with my stats is wrong.
It's about my attack speed.

So, all attack speed % bonuses which I have are:
+10% from 1 sword
+10% from 2nd sword
+28% from maxed Blood frenzy (10% at lv1 + 2% each level = 10% + 9*2%)

That's a total of 48% bonus of my base attack speed when I wield both swords.

My base attack speed is 140 (No swords, no blood frenzy bonus).
When I put one of my swords on, it increases to 154 (+14 as a 10% bonus). However, when I put my second sword, I'm supposed to get +14 (from 10% bonus of second sword) and +39 from Blood Frenzy, which leaves me at 207 attack speed. 140+14+14+39=207, or 1,48*140=207

But, my attack speed isn't 207, it's 201.

I tried asking a guildmate to do the same thing (Take his swords off, put one sword, put the other) and his attack speed seemed to stack correctly.

Either I'm messing something up in my maths or this is bugged. Please help me out.

@Zankza

 

[Arderyan]

"After doing rounds of tests, it seems like the official skill descriptions are either wrong, or are calculated separately from the other aspd bonuses. Based on what I have found, Blood Frenzy starts off at 11%, and raises attack speed by 1% every level thereafter."

http://pirate.mmosite.com/guide/crusader_guide_formulas.shtml#part1

May be because of this, didn't test myself.

 

[Leba]

"After doing rounds of tests, it seems like the official skill descriptions are either wrong, or are calculated separately from the other aspd bonuses. Based on what I have found, Blood Frenzy starts off at 11%, and raises attack speed by 1% every level thereafter."

http://pirate.mmosite.com/guide/crusader_guide_formulas.shtml#part1

May be because of this, didn't test myself.

It would be 20% at lv10 then. My aspd should be 5 lower than it is now if that's true.

 

[FinalLegacy]

I've done experiments just the other day and found out aspd was calculated this way:

aspd = base*1.2(total for eqs)*1.2(blood frenzy) for your case.

if you have buff it would be

aspd = base*1.2*1.35, where 20% is from BF and 15 is from TB.

with max zerk it should be:

aspd = base*1.2*1.70, since zerk gives 35%

skill aspd bonuses are added together and eq aspd bonuses are added together. Try it out and let me know if it actually works for you.

EDIT: didn't read through your whole post and did the calculation I used on your base aspd and it works. I got 201.6 and it's always rounded down.

EDIT2: I thought I should also mention that Tempest boost desc is also misleading as it says it starts at 6% and increases 13% per level. Obviously from my calculations, it starts at 6% and increases 1% per level. Cheers

 

[Leba]

aspd = base*1.2(total for eqs)*1.2(blood frenzy) for your case.

I had no idea attack speed stacks multiplicatively and it honestly sucks that Blood frenzy's description is wrong. (You put 1.2 instead of 1.28 which the skill obviously implies).

Either way thanks, guess it was the faulty skill description as well as me thinking that attack speed stacks additively. At least I can rest easy now.

 

[MZarur]

ehh, that's a good thing to be pointed.. i don't know exactly how does the % bonus works, but if we assume that it only affects ur base, you would have 140 + (140*0,48) that is 207,2 aspd that is 207. and i think that it's the worst case. cuz if the % bonus stacks, you would have a bit more. like: 140 + (140*0.1) = 154. 154 + (154*0.1) = 169. 169 + (169*0.28) = 216. that should be the best case...

 

[Leba]

ehh, that's a good thing to be pointed.. i don't know exactly how does the % bonus works, but if we assume that it only affects ur base, you would have 140 + (140*0,48) that is 207,2 aspd that is 207. and i think that it's the worst case. cuz if the % bonus stacks, you would have a bit more. like: 140 + (140*0.1) = 154. 154 + (154*0.1) = 169. 169 + (169*0.28) = 216. that should be the best case...

I guess everything %-based is looked at base attack speed, and it stacks multiplicatively. So as it was pointed out, 140*1,2*1,2=201. But damn it sucks that the blood frenzy tooltip is so misleading. If it were 0.28, it would be 140*1,2*1,28=215

Any chance to get a fix on that and one last confirmation about how attack speed % from gear and skills works? @Zankza