Ok I figured out what I was doing wrong. I was at the wrong place, but now have another problem.
I place all required items into each slot, but something as simple as lvl 1 bread that is at 100% success is failing. I do have a full stack of fairy coins in my inventory.
My Cooking skill lvl is lvl 3 and my pet is lvl 4 with standard cooking. Lvl 1 cooking Bp is failing and I can not figure it out.
Please help